MidAtlantic Biosolids Association

Biosolids NewsClips - April 11, 2025

The April NewsClips predominantly features articles concerning PFAS in biosolids and wastewater industries. Many articles discuss potential actions to control PFAS, but these actions primarily focus on biosolids rather than consumer products. There's concern that the EPA Draft Risk Assessment is being presented as conclusive, and it is being used to encourage banning the land application of biosolids.

Several articles highlight instances where biosolids are blamed for PFAS contamination without sufficient evidence. For example, wells near a beef farm using EQ Biosolids with high fecal coliform are attributed to biosolids, despite beef manure being a more likely source. In Bloomsburg, PA, the PA DEP is blaming biosolids spreading from the 1980s with no further details.

Some articles call for a complete reduction in PFAS manufacturing and use, along with a ban on land application and incineration of biosolids. One article mentions that there were concerns that chemicals in sludge from a PA alkaline stabilization site (formerly known as Blackwood) could migrate into drinking water. The request for expansion at this site is also being opposed because of odors.

However, there are also some counterpoints and nuances presented. Maryland legislation limiting PFAS in biosolids to 1 PPB (based on the EPA Draft Risk Assessment) was struck down. DC Water stated that no specific study shows its soil product leaching chemicals into groundwater, suggesting that people face far more PFOS exposure from common household items like microwavable popcorn. An article from East Lansing, Michigan, emphasizes the importance of screening biosolids before field application and cautions against broad bans without knowing the specific problems. 

A positive article by Sally Brown of "U dub" is included and is planned to be shared with Lancaster Farming. 

As always, MABA is committed to keeping members informed and engaged. If you have biosolids news to share or would like to join the Communications Committee, please contact Mary Baker at 845-901-7905 or [email protected].

Biosolids News 
(as of April 2, 2025)
 
MABA Region

Reservoir neighbors remain frustrated with polluted water, lack of response
New Scotland, NY (5 Mar 2025) - Residents continue to raise the alarm about the cancer-causing compounds found in their drinking water supply. A farmer, who has property across from the Dunhams, had always sprayed manure on his field, which smelled for a day and then was fine, Dunham said. The trouble began when the farmer switched to fertilizing with biosolids, made from sewer sludge, Dunham said.
Water questions keep bubbling up: neither DEC or Albany County investigate cause of water contamination in New Scotland
Opinion: One family’s hardship makes clear the need to ban use of toxin-laced sewage sludge as fertilizer

Op-Ed: Whatever Are We to Do?
Washington, DC (7 Mar 2025) - If you are a farmer who has spread biosolids to fertilize, you might well wonder, “They swore this stuff was safe! What’s next?” Our series has examined this rebranded sewage sludge, who really profits, how this spreading continues, and why it matters to all of us. The scope of the problem is huge: 35 million tons of sludge are created every year. The degree of contamination varies, but all sludge contains toxics including PFAS. The EPA says there is NO safe level.  Once any of this class of 15,000 chemicals makes its way into our nation’s sewers, these extraordinarily poisonous and highly persistent fluorocarbons pass through Waste Water Treatment Plants.

Carbon rallies against sludge
Lehighton, PA (8 Mar 2025) - A group aimed at helping Carbon County’s residents and the environment thanked the county commissioners for taking a stand against sewage sludge being used on farmlands.On Thursday, members of Save Carbon County addressed the board, thanking them for last month’s action in adopting a resolution calling for further state and federal officials and agencies to investigate the potential effects of land application of sewage sludge within Carbon County. Linda Christman, president of Save Carbon County, said it was good to see further action on the matter. She provided the county with the draft risk assessment from the EPA, which she said states that the products grown on farms using sewage sludge can have high levels of PFAs or forever chemicals, which can be carcinogenic.
Save Carbon addresses board about sludge

Opinion: We’re facing a ‘forever chemicals’ crisis. We must stop Pfas at the source
New York, NY (10 Mar 2025) - Several years ago, I made a movie called Dark Waters, which told the real-life story of a community in West Virginia poisoned by Pfas “forever chemicals”. DuPont – a chemical manufacturing plant – contaminated the local water supply, killing cows and wildlife, making its workers sick and exposing local residents to toxic chemicals. It was an environmental horror story.Yet, despite knowing the risks, the federal government – through the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) – has actually encouraged farmers to spread sewage sludge contaminated with Pfas across cropland and pastures (as the New York Times has reported in multiple stories). This sludge, a byproduct of wastewater treatment, seeps into the soil, contaminates groundwater and ends up in our food. And from there? It ends up in us.

Comment Period Closing in 30 Days (April 16) on Federal PFOA/PFOS Risk Assessment for Sewage Sludge Applied to Agricultural Land as Fertilizer
Washington, DC (19 Mar 2025) - Interested parties—including businesses raising crops or animals on agricultural and ranch lands potentially impacted by PFAS in groundwater; entities operating wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs); and related interest groups and associations—should be aware that the public comment period closes in one month, on April 16, 2025, for EPA’s Draft Sewage Sludge Risk Assessment for Perfluorooctanoic Acid (PFOA) and Perfluorooctane Sulfonic Acid (PFOS), notice of which was published on January 15, 2025 (90 Fed. Reg. 3859). The original comment period was scheduled to end on March 17. However, on February 22, EPA extended the comment period to April 16, to “allow interested parties additional time to thoroughly review and analyze” the risk assessment. See 90 Fed. Reg. 10078 (Feb. 22, 2025).

Opinion: What’s in the millions of tonnes of sludge spread on to UK farmland? Toxic waste – and ministers don’t care
New York, NY (21 Mar 2025) - If humanity has an epitaph, it might read something like this: “Knackered by the things we missed.” It is true that several existential threats are widely known and widely discussed. But some of the greatest dangers we face appear on almost no one’s radar. How often have you thought about this one: spreading sewage sludge on farmland? I would guess very few would include it in their top civilisational hazards. Despite the best efforts of a handful of us, it trundles on, unknown to most. Surprising as it may seem, new research suggests that it could help call time on us.

Weekly roundup: Farm lawsuit, toxic sewage sludge expansion
Pottsville, PA (21 Mar 2025) - Liberty Soils Biosolids Management Facility on the Blackwood Inc. mine site in Reilly, Branch and Tremont Twps., has submitted an application to expand its sewage sludge operation to accept 500 tons of biosolids a day. There are many chemicals of concern turning up in sludge, but perhaps most concerning are the PFAS or “forever” chemicals, which are linked to several diseases and certain cancers. Farmers in Schuylkill County can legally apply the sludge to fields, which threatens the land, neighbors and the food supply with toxic contamination. When it rains, the chemicals in the sludge can migrate into drinking water supplies.
Commissioners oppose biosolids company expansion

‘Forever chemicals’ in the community: DEP says sewage from the 1980s likely threatens Columbia County’s health
Pittston, PA (21 Mar 2025) - The DEP started its investigation into groundwater and wells near the Brookside Village Mobile Home Park, where contamination was first detected last April after routine water testing. The agency discovered dangerously high levels of PFAS. The contamination was likely from sewage sludge, also known as biosolids, used as fertilizer on nearby farms in the 1980s, according to DEP. The sludge is the byproduct of wastewater treatment. DEP is also testing a former electroplating operation in the area for contamination.

Lawmakers clash over PFAS limits in farming sludge
Annapolis, MD (24 Mar 2025) - Maryland lawmakers are struggling to advance legislation aimed at limiting the presence of toxic "forever chemicals" in sewage sludge used as soil conditioner—a predominant source of PFAS contamination in the state's environment, according to scientists studying the issue. The bill, which has faced stiff opposition due to its potential economic impact, is undergoing revisions in a last-ditch effort to stay alive.  A hearing on an amendment that would weaken the proposed limits is scheduled for Tuesday. At the heart of the debate is Maryland Senate Bill 732, which seeks to restrict levels of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) in treated sewage sludge spread on agricultural land. PFAS chemicals, widely used in non-stick cookware, stain-resistant fabrics, and firefighting foam, do not break down over time and have been linked to cancer and other health risks at extremely low exposure levels. 
Political notes: ‘Madness’ in the House, another FAMLI delay, a sludge slump
'Forever Chemical' legislation in Maryland fails

Sewage sludge can find a second life on farm fields. Here’s how it’s made
New York, NY (26 Mar 2025) - What goes down your toilet can end up on farm fields across the United States.
Biosolids, or sewage sludge, are the solid byproducts of the wastewater treatment process. Rich in nutrients, they can be used as fertilizer on agricultural fields or compost on lawns. But the process for producing these materials can vary greatly, and some unwanted things can end up in those biosolids. A recent study released by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency suggested that human health risks associated with toxic per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) were elevated in some places where sludge was applied to farm fields.

Nationally

USU researcher focuses on keeping ‘forever chemicals’ out of our water, food
Logan, UT (3 Mar 2025) - A research project at Utah State University is targeting so-called ‘forever chemicals’ that often end up in our groundwater and ultimately in some food sources. The harmful compounds are more commonly known in the science community as polyfluoroalkyl substances, or PFAS. Dr. Ryan Dupont, a professor in civil and environmental engineering, said PFAS are found just about everywhere. Researchers on Dupont’s team are targeting the sludge that wastewater treatment plants often turn into compost. He said the compost, in turn, feeds plants that animals eat, which then end up in our food chain.

County sued over its biosolid ordinance by Biocycle, LLC
Bartholomew County, IN (4 Mar 2025) - A lawsuit has been filed against the Bartholomew County commissioners claiming a sewer sludge storage ordinance is unconstitutional. Biocycle, LLC v. Bartholomew County Board of County Commissioners was filed Feb. 17 in Bartholomew Circuit Court. Daily said during public hearings at the time he felt the commissioners passed an illegal ordinance that mainly affects his farm operation and limits what biosolids he can use. 
Greensburg asks IDEM for permit to spread its biosolids in Bartholomew County

City Council considering a 5-year extension to biosolid program
Omaha, NE (4 Mar 2025) - For years, the city has kept sewage sludge out of the landfill with the help of area farmers. Now, city council is considering extending the agreement with even more farmers. In 2024 the program diverted nearly 96,000 cubic yards of sewage sludge from the landfill. The program pays farmers to take the waste and use it on their land. By doing this, City Council president Pete Festersen says it saves the city over $2 million in landfill fees.

CBPU Board approves biosolids contract with Sexton Farms
Coldwater, MI (6 Mar 2025) - he Coldwater Board of Public Utilities Board of Directors approved the renewal of a three year contract with Sexton Farms on Wednesday night to haul and land apply biosolids from the Water Resource Recovery Facility. The contract would be in effect from May 1 through April of 2028. The CBPU has contracted with Sexton Farms for six years. Prior to that, this was contracted through a third-party from outside of the region. Water Superintendent Brian Musselman said the price increase from three cents to four cents a gallon is worth it.

Forever chemicals in biosolids may pose problems for municipalities, farmers
East Lansing, MI (7 Mar 2025) - A common practice by farmers to fertilize their fields may be spreading forever chemicals into new areas and into the food supply. Biosolids are nutrient-rich organic materials derived from the treatment of sewage sludge from wastewater treatment plants that are applied as fertilizer. They can be a cost-effective way for local governments to dispose of sewage sludge and for farmers who pay little or nothing to use it as fertilizer.

Op-Ed: Right Goal, Wrong Direction
Seattle, WA (10 Mar 2025) - In the final days of the Biden administration, the Environmental Protection Agency released a draft report assessing the risk of biosolids – that’s the term for a fertilizer recycled from our wastewater — as it pertains to PFAS (per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances), commonly known as “forever chemicals.” This group of 3,000-plus manmade chemicals permeate virtually every aspect of our lives: they are in cookware, food packaging, carpets, cleaning products, and cosmetics, to name a few. The authors used the extremely low-end numbers of 1 part per billion of perfluorooctanoic acid and perfluorooctane sulfonic acid, to model the hypothetical risks of PFAS to a family using biosolids on their farm. To put this number in perspective, dental floss contains an average of 2.5 million parts per billion of PFAS. The rainwater itself contains more PFAS than their hypothetical biosolids application, and yet none of these sources were taken into account by the report.

Senate passes Sen. Jeff Wilson’s bill to assess ‘forever chemical’ contamination in food supply
Centralia, WA (10 Mar 2025) - A bill by state Sen. Jeff Wilson, R-Longview, passed the Senate for the second time Friday, calling attention to possible forever-chemical contamination in Washington’s food supply due to the use of biosolid fertilizers on fields where crops are grown, according to a news release from Wilson. Senate Bill 5033 would launch a testing program to assess contamination levels in processed human waste currently used as fertilizers for farms and forests. Wilson’s bill requires the state Department of Ecology to establish a testing program for perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl (PFAS) compounds in biosolids by July 1, 2028.

PFAS Contaminated a Texas County’s Farms, Threatening Animals, Water and Public Health
Johnson County, TX (12 Mar 2025) - Johnson County’s long saga with PFAS started in 2022, with an influx of calls to Detective Dana Ames, an environmental crimes investigator for the Texas county located just south of Fort Worth. More than two years later, county officials declared a state of disaster, as testing pointed to high levels of PFAS in the county’s farmland. PFAS stands for per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances, also dubbed “forever chemicals” because they require much longer spans of time to break down in soils. But in Johnson county, officials attributed these high levels of PFAS to a form of processed waste called biosolids — also known as sewage sludge — that were applied to farms as fertilizer to boost crop fertility.
Fort Worth sues feds, companies for $420M in damages from forever chemicals in water
Synagro Releases Conclusions of Independent Scientific Study on Biosolids in Johnson County, Texas
Synagro seeks to dismiss lawsuit over PFAS in its biosolids, citing new research
Officials seek state of emergency after discovering health hazard lurking in widely used product: 'This is uncharted territory'
Fort Worth water utility to take over operations at biosolids plant blamed for foul smell, dead livestock

DPU Pulls Back Curtain On WRRF
Los Alamos, NM (13 Mar 2025) - Oh, the mysteries of plumbing. What secrets travel along the maze of pipes that ultimately wind up at a wastewater treatment plant or in White Rock’s case, the White Rock Water Resource Reclamation Facility (WRRF)? Department of Public Utilities staff decided to pull back the curtain and show the community the answer. The first public tour of the WRRF, which went online just last year, was held March 5. It was led by Wastewater Treatment Superintendent Josh Silva. Another tour will be held April 9 and a third is scheduled for May 14. The tours are open to everyone, though space is limited, and are free of charge.

House bill addresses city sewage sludge
Mt. Pleasant, IA (14 Mar 2025) - This week we debated and voted on nearly 50 bills on the House floor. I was floor manager for two of those bills, and I will get to those in a second, but first I want to talk about a bill I introduced to address the issue of city sewage sludge being spread on farmland. For some time, various cities across the country have paid farmers to haul the sludge from their sewage treatment plants and spread it on their cropland. This was viewed as a win-win solution: cities got rid off their sewage sludge, and farmers received “free” fertilizer. Some of the toxins found in sewage sludge are PFAs, often called “forever chemicals.” The EPA has said that PFAs are unsafe for humans in drinking water at any level.

How do we address the problem of PFAS in sewage sludge?
Champaign County, IL (20 Mar 2025) - Communities and federal agencies are waking up to the dangers of “forever chemicals” in wastewater treatment sludge, which is often sprayed on farm fields as fertilizer. In mid-January, the federal Environmental Protection Agency warned that this practice endangers human health. A month later, Johnson County in northeast Texas declared a state of emergency over the contamination of farm fields with per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances, or PFAS, from sewage sludge. John Scott, a research scientist at the Illinois Sustainable Technology Center who studies PFAS in wastewater treatment facilities and landfills, spoke with News Bureau life sciences editor Diana Yates about the problem.

City utilities considers drying biosolids
Columbus, IN (21 Mar 2025) - Columbus City Utilities (CCU) board members are discussing beginning to dry biosolids and embarking on a new project to enable that, something officials said is in utility’s best interest for long-term resiliency. Travis Calhoun, associate director of treatment operations, and Ashley Getz, associate director of engineering, set the stage for board members during a meeting on Thursday explaining how the biosolids program operates now, talked about concerns they had regarding continuing on with the program as is and then presented what biosolids drying would look like and its benefits.

Round Mountain Water proposes to spread sewage sludge on local ranch
Westcliffe, CO (22 Mar 2025) - On March 6, the company that was hired by Round Mountain Water and Sanitation District, Denali Water Systems, filed an application with the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment to take the biosolids from the lagoons and spread them on a property south of Westcliffe over 150 acres of dry grazing ground for fertilizer. The land was actually owned by Round Mountain Water and Sanitation District until 2022. This land was known locally as the Johnson Ranch and was purchased by Round Mountain Water and Sanitation District in 2000 so that the water district could have the water rights and use them for the towns. The land was sold in 2022 for $1.5 million to an Illinios industrial chicken egg farmer, Joseph Kropf who has a house in Pueblo.
Editorial: Spreading sewage sludge is a risk and requires the precautionary principle
Sludge company giving special presentation to Custer Commissioners at 5 p.m. in Westcliffe

Salem utilities officials talk wastewater treatment plant project progress
Salem, OH (24 Mar 2025) - The utilities commission discussed the rate of progress for phase three improvements at the wastewater treatment plant in its meeting Thursday. Burgess and Niple Contract Administrator Don Tych said that the trickling filter station has been renovated with new pipes and valves, and that the new pumps were ready to be set in place. Progress is also continuing in the sludge dewatering and sludge conditioning building. He said that the conveyor system in the sludge dewatering building had been roughed in and were “98% complete,” process piping in the sludge conditioning building was about 50% complete, waste gas piping for the anaerobic digestor had been completed and tested, and the primary tank roof inspection had been completed.

Kalamazoo seeks loan to tackle wastewater odor and infrastructure issues
Kalamazoo, MI (25 Mar 2025) - The city has just made the public aware of its plan to hopefully obtain portions of a nearly $200 million loan that would help dismantle the odor many residents have complained about over the years. The loan is a part of a low-interest financing program called "water state revolving loan fund," or CWSRF. “It’s a wet process in that we manage, we store, we process, we haul wet material to the landfill that creates that odor that’s an impact for our community and our neighbors,” James Baker, City of Kalamazoo public services director and city engineer, said.

Tennessee bill aims to give Grundy County power to regulate use of biosolids on farmland
Grundy County, TN (26 Mar 2025) - A bill is making its way through Tennessee legislature that would give Grundy County the legal authority to regulate the application of human sewage on farmland in the community. This comes after concerns from county officials and residents who have been asking for regulations to protect them from the smell and runoff. According to permit documents from TDEC, more than a dozen farms in Grundy County are getting biosolids delivered from the Moccasin Bend treatment plant in Chattanooga. Current law prohibits counties from prohibiting or regulating normal agricultural activities.

Tulsa councilors worried biosolids bill will hike sewer bills
Tulsa, OK (27 Mar 2025) - Well intentioned, Senate Bill 3 states "To protect the health and safety of the people of this state, land application of sludge and biosolid material is hereby prohibited on and after July 1, 2027." It passed 42 to 4. But then the biosolids hit the fan. "If this goes through as is it’s going to have a huge financial impact on the city," said Tulsa city councilor Phil Lakin. "Quite honestly I think the poo bill stinks," :said Tulsa city councilor Carol Bush. Both councilors, holding their noses on the economic impact of the bill if it were to become law. "The estimates that we received yesterday was that it could cost us $10 million more a year just to do it after a capital investment of about $100 million dollars," said Lakin.
Timeline for biosolids bill too fast say local officials
Bill to ban sewage sludge as fertilizer wins Oklahoma Senate approval

Meriden proposes hikes in water and sewer rates over maintenance, disposal, equipment costs
Meriden, CT (31 Mar 2025) - City residents can expect to see increases in their water and sewer bills due to state and federal laws mandating phosphorus removal from water, removal of lead pipes from homes and steep jumps in biosolids disposal costs. According to City Manager Brian Daniels' proposed budget, water rates will increase from $5.7 per 100 cubic feet for water to $6.12 per 100 cubic feet. If the budget is approved sewer rates will increase 5.5 percent from $6.49 per cubic foot to $6.85. 

Internationally

Plan to graze horses on former sewage site refused
Ossett, England (9 Mar 2025) - Plans to graze horses on land previously used to treat sewage have been rejected over animal safety concerns. An applicant had hoped to use a former Yorkshire Water site off Spa Lane in Ossett as pasture land for up to five horses. But a planning officer's report to Wakefield Council raised the risk of soil being contaminated with harmful toxic metals including arsenic and mercury. The council said the application failed to show the site was safe for grazing due to its "historic use for the drying of sludge associated with the former Ossett sewage works".

Biosolids hold untapped potential — using them can revolutionise Indian farming
New Delhi, India (10 Mar 2025) - Agriculture in India is a key sector of the nation’s economy, employing approximately 60 per cent of the population and contributing significantly to the country’s gross domestic product or GDP. However, it faces major challenges such as soil degradation, water scarcity and the overuse of chemical fertilisers, raising concerns about sustainability and environmental health. Biosolids are increasingly being used in agriculture, either formally or informally, as organic fertilisers, particularly in areas where farmers seek cost-effective alternatives to chemical fertilisers. The use of biosolids could help reduce dependence on chemical fertilisers, lower farming costs and improve soil fertility.

Regional septage facility being considered in Chilliwack
Chilliwack, British Columbia, Canada (Mar 11 2025) - A regional septage facility could be constructed on reserve land just north of Highway 1 in Chilliwack. According to a PowerPoint slide presentation from Monday night’s District of Hope council meeting, Leq’á:mel Development Corporation and YieldBridge Industries Ltd. provided an overview outlining the proposed septage and biosolids processing facility. Two locations are being envisioned for the project, including Lackaway Indian Reserve No. 2, located west of Lickman Road and north of Industrial Way, and Papekwatchin, located north of the Fraser River and southwest of Deroche.

Solar-powered tech turns sewage sludge into green hydrogen and animal feed
Singapore (12 Mar 2025) - Scientists at NTU Singapore, have developed an innovative solar-powered method to transform sewage sludge - a by-product of wastewater treatment - into green hydrogen for clean energy and single-cell protein for animal feed. Published in Nature Water, the sludge-to-food-and-fuel method tackles two pressing global challenges: managing waste and generating sustainable resources. Proof-of-concept tests revealed that the NTU team’s process is more efficient than conventional techniques like anaerobic digestion - through which bacteria break down organic waste to produce biogas and nutrient-rich residue. It recovers significantly more resources, completely removes heavy metal contaminants, has a smaller environmental footprint, and offers better economic feasibility.
Pollutant-eating sewage bacteria offer hope for environmental cleanup

Prevalence of microplastics in soil increased 15 times in four years – study
Glasgow, Scotland (13 Mar 2025) - The research also found the number of microplastics in the soil remained relatively unchanged 22 years after application. Microplastics are pieces of plastic measuring less than 5mm and can be manufactured intentionally, such as in cosmetics, or broken off from larger pieces of plastic. Sewage sludge is commonly used to fertilise farmland around the world, and contains large amounts of microplastics, which are released into the soil.

A new way of dealing with wastewater sludge at Delta's Annacis plant
Ladner, British Columbia, Canada (17 Mar 2025) - A demonstration-scale project for a new use of wastewater sludge is coming to the Annacis Island Wastewater Treatment Plant in Delta.Metro Vancouver’s Liquid Waste Committee recently endorsed recommendation be forwarded to the regional district’s board to approve a $12 million contract for site preparation, installation, tie-in connections and commissioning of the Annacis Island Wastewater Treatment Plant Hydrothermal Liquefaction (HTL) Demonstration Plant. HTL converts wastewater sludge into biocrude, instead of producing biosolids. The biocrude can then be refined into low-carbon transportation fuels.

Quebec adopts new code to regulate 'forever chemicals' in biosolids
Montreal, Quebec, Canada (18 Mar 2025) - The presence and concentration of PFAS, also known as "forever chemicals," in fertilizing residual materials will be monitored under new standards in Quebec through a management code, according to Quebec's Environment Ministry. Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances are a class of thousands of chemicals used in a wide range of products, from food containers to clothing to natural fertilizers. Quebec's code on the management of fertilizing residual materials such as sewage sludge, also sometimes known as biosolids — which come from treating municipal or industrial wastewater — will take effect Nov. 1.

Odour may be smelled during maintenance at McLoughlin Point Wastewater Treatment Plant: CRD
Capital Regional District, British Columbia, Canada (26 Mar 2025) - The Capital Regional District is notifying residents of possible “localized odour generation” during maintenance at the McLoughlin Point Wastewater Treatment Plant in Esquimalt. Maintenance at the wastewater treatment plant kicked off Wednesday, and will include a 21-day sewage bypass between March 26 and April 16. During the bypass, sewage that has undergone primary treatment will be released at an outfall located two kilometres into the Strait of Juan de Fuca.

 

April 2025 - Sally Brown Research Library & Commentary

Sally Brown

Provided for consideration to MABA members by
Sally Brown, PhD., University of Washington


April Showers

May flowers are just around the corner. That means that we are still in the middle of those April showers. Here in Seattle those showers are pretty much a fixture of life from October onwards. Seems like those showers last forever. While the showers will go away, they will leave telltale signs other than flowers. You guessed it! More PFAS. This seemed like an opportune time to do a library on PFAS in rainwater. Read on and don’t despair. The May library will go back to the benefits of biosolids.

sb1

We start this library with an article by Chris Higgins: A Never-Ending Story of Per- and Poly fluoroalkyl Substances (PFASs)? For me, this paper is a very effective cheat sheet at keeping track of the PFAS family tree. The first figure in the paper has a great map of the different classes/ compounds - see below:

sb2

You can use that as a cheat sheet. I find it exceedingly difficult to keep all of the classes/ compounds/ precursors in order. This is a helpful guide. The paper is a good general summary of the ubiquity of PFAS compounds, the industrial policy of replacing banned compounds with very similar surrogates and the issues re health, persistence and toxicity. 

Paper #2 : Contamination levels of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) in recent North American precipitation events. A review takes us right to the topic. The authors provide a very broad summary here. This includes a review of data from rainwater sampling in different parts of the US, information on what types of rain are more likely to carry PFAS, and PFAS in groundwater. If you are near a local source of PFAS, thunderstorms or convective events are much higher than for stratiform (broad low pressure systems) events. Groundwaters in urban areas where PFAS manufacturing or use occurs have much higher PFAS concentrations than urban areas without manufacturing. However, they all have it. Collecting rainwater from roof tops can provide water self-sufficiency but roof top materials can be a source of PFAS. The authors also detail the different drinking water regulations in the US and the EU and describe the role of the Hazard Index (HI) in setting limits. There is also a discussion of half-lives of the different compounds. Us older women and men in general take longer to rid ourselves of PFAS than younger women. The size and shape of the compounds also makes a difference. Below is a table with summaries of different rain sampling studies. The Arizona study likely shows the impact of roofing materials. If you want low PFAS in your rainwater you might consider a move to Massachusetts. Also good for foliage.

 
sb3
sb4
 
Paper #3 It’s raining PFAS in South Florida: Occurrence of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) in wet atmospheric deposition from Miami-Dade, South Florida provides yet another reason to cross Florida off of your list. The authors collected rainwater samples from the Miami Dade region and analyzed them for PFAS. PFAS was found in 95% of the samples. The majority were PFCAs with a much smaller detection frequency for PFSAs (see figure below). Now would be the time to refer back to that handy figure from paper #1. 

sb5

The authors note that longer chain compounds are more prevalent in rainfall during the dryer portion of the year. Likely as a result of being attached to suspended dust that comes down with the rain. Shorter chain particles, typically more water soluble, are found during the wetter portion of the year. Realize that there are no known industrial sources of PFAS in this sampling area. The authors consider airborne dust from Africa as a contributing source. 

Papers #4 Correlation Analysis of Perfluoroalkyl Substances in Regional U.S. Precipitation Events and #5 Non-targeted identification and semi-quantitation of emerging per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) in US rainwater are from the same group and reference the same group of samples. The authors collected rainwater samples on a transect from Ohio/ Indiana to Wyoming. The first study focused on well known types of PFAS with the second focusing on up and coming versions. The sites followed the pattern of the wind with the WY site located > 5000 km away, serving as an example of an isolated site away from any potential urban sources. Trifluoroacetic acid (TCA) was the big winner in the first study, comprising 90% of the identified PFAS. The authors showed the distribution of PFAS in a number of ways including by general family and by chain length for each location.

sb6 

While Wooster, OH was the worst overall, Jackson Hole wasn’t exactly pristine, being statistically similar to many of the other areas sampled. Forget about not eating the yellow snow in Jackson, you better not eat the white stuff either. The distribution of the types of PFAS also varied for some sites, suggesting point sources with their own special blends. 

In the follow up study the authors used a different analytical technique on the same samples. I would open my umbrella for this one. With this different technique they identified several emerging types of PFAS with the C3-C8 hydrogen substituted perfluorocarboxylic acids (H-PFCAs and fluorotelomer carboxylic acids (FTCAs) being the most common. The total concentrations of these newbies was 1-2 orders of magnitude greater than for the more traditional compounds ranging from 10-1000 ng L 1, except for poor Wooster, OH where the sum topped out at 16 400 ng L-1. Here you can see the old and the new side by side.

sb7

Let me just point out that biosolids were not mentioned as the source of the PFAS in any of these articles. Once again, let me remind you that this problem is much bigger than the biosolids. Burning the biosolids won’t stop the rain.
 
Sally Brown is a Research Associate Professor at the University of Washington, and she is also a columnist and editorial board member for BioCycle magazine.  

Do you have information or research to share with MABA members? Looking for other research focus or ideas?

Contact Mary Baker at [email protected] or 845-901-7905.

 

Important Update for MABA Members:
Results from the 2nd National Survey of Biosolids Regulation, Quality, End Use and Disposal in the U.S.

The National Biosolids Data Project (NBDP) has been recently unveiled. You are invited to its comprehensive, user-friendly, data-rich website: http://biosolidsdata.org.  This website provides both a national overview of biosolids generation and utilization/disposal in the target year 2018, but, importantly and most usefully for practitioners in the mid-Atlantic region, the NBDP also includes state summary reports.  Your MABA staff and volunteers are assembling a webpage which will allow quick access to the state reports in our region. 

This NBDP data site was prepared over a two-year period. It was accomplished on a shoe-string budget of about $60,000, with a small EPA grant and some financial contributions from WEF, NACWA and public agencies, and with many hours of volunteer time. The focus  is comprehensive, with details on technologies, particularly the distinction of Class A and Class B levels of pathogen treatment, with categories of utilization outlets and products (compost versus pellets), with capture of landfill and incineration disposal, and with an overview of each state’s regulations. 

A key feature of the project was the survey of water resource recovery facilities (WRRFs), generators of biosolids.  The survey had 452 valid and representative responses from WRRFs in 43 states and DC. This is a set that comprises a flow of about 12,000 MGD, or 34% of total municipal effluent flows in the United States. When generously supplied by public agencies, surveys provided in addition to mass of biosolids and uses, information on pollutant concentrations, program costs and points of view on hurdles and barriers. In a few cases, the surveys of state officials were able to elicit information on septage management.  The EPA biosolids records for 2018 in ECHO (Enforcement and Compliance History Online) was also brought into the analysis. 

Every effort was made to provide comparable data across all states, but this goal was elusive. In the end, the data reports of 32 states were judged of high confidence, 12 were of moderate confidence and 4 of low confidence.  Every state office responsible for biosolids management was afforded an opportunity to review and correct its state’s data and description.  

While this richly compiled database might clearly have commercial value, the results are freely available and are intended to aid in the transparency of biosolids programs to the public. 

Ned Beecher, for 20 years executive director of NEBRA and then special projects coordinator for the early PFAS response,  is the principal investigator for this “second” survey. He was the principal designer of the two surveys (one for state officials and the other for public agencies) and of the database, though with much feedback along the way, Ned had been also the leader of the first survey, which was released fifteen years ago, July 2007, based on biosolids generation and use in 2004, which explains in part the ambitious goals of the current survey. 

Many biosolids practitioners over the years had come to rely on this first survey. It was clear to all who used it recently that the first survey had become dated. Ned took on this herculean project, and now with its completion, we can give hearty kudos to Ned for his vision and persistence. Today you will note from Ned’s email communications that he is now the “former” special project manager for NEBRA and available for hire.  But updates to the second survey, whether to correct or amplify it, or to change it to reflect new developments, will need to be shouldered by others, and we await these folks to emerge and step forward. 

The survey year of 2018 may have the feel of “historical” today. But, at the opening of the project in mid-2020, this was the year most likely to be complete in its data set from federal, state, and municipal sources. The project was intended to be completed by Spring 2021, but whether a victim of pandemic staffing challenges or from competing issues for biosolids practitioners, data collection for this new survey was a slog.  In the mid-Atlantic region, the year 2018 had an atypical influence of large rainfall volumes, and in the Northeast region the discovery of perfluoroalkyl substances disrupted programs. 

Here is the big reveal!  Total biosolids used or disposed of in the U. S. in 2018 was 5,823,000 dry metric tons (dmt). This compares to 6,132,000 dmt reported in the 2004 survey.  This decline in total biosolids was a surprise to the NBDP team. The decline may reflect less double counting than in 2004 of solids hauled from small to larger plants for treatment, or in some locations it may reflect a shift from alkaline stabilization to digestion, the latter technology reducing total dry solids. The 2018 database involved fewer estimations, particularly of biosolids production at small WRRFs. With the estimation in this second survey of the sewered population served, the total national average per capita production of biosolids annually is 37 pounds. That agencies and states show a wide range around this average suggests other aspects at play, perhaps the proportion of combined sewer systems and the acceptance of septage from unsewered areas. 

Here is the second big reveal.  Fifty-three percent of biosolids produced in the United States in 2018 were beneficially used. Within this number are some important findings.  More Class A EQ biosolids are being produced in 2018 than in 2004. Despite policies for organics diversion from municipal waste landfills in some states and regions, the same percentage of biosolids are commingled with municipal waste in 2018 as in 2004.  The percentage of biosolids fed to incinerators has declined, with a fewer number of sewage sludge incinerators in operation.  The survey showed, too, decreased full time equivalent (FTE) employees regulating biosolids at state and federal agencies.  As our industry has asserted in the past, the proportion of our nation's croplands receiving biosolids as a nutrient source is very small, less than 1%.

The Mid Atlantic Biosolids Association participated in the NBDP project. It reviewed electronic record reports to the EPA and state environmental agencies, and also surveyed state officials and larger public agencies.  In the work covering the 7 states and one district in this region, the NBPD documented that the over 1,800 significant POTWs serve 50 million “sewered” customers, producing 1.3 million dry tons of biosolids annually. Sixteen WRRFs in the region produce over 10,000 dmt. NYCDEP is largest agency (~100,000 dmt), and in descending order are Philadelphia Water Department, DC Water, Passaic Valley Water Commission, Middlesex County Utility Authority, Baltimore Department of Public Works, ALCOSAN (Allegheny County, PA), Hampton Roads Sanitation District (VA), City of Rochester (NY), DELCORA, Bergen County Utility Authority (NJ), Suffolk County (NY), Arlington County (VA), Nassau County (NY), and Fairfax County (VA). The average per capita annual biosolids production in the MABA region is 54 dry pounds.

The NBDP state reports include narratives describing notable facilities and programs that serve to treat and use biosolids. In the MABA region report are these distinctive points. Composting is a major treatment technology in the region (e.g., Burlington Co, Rockland Co, Baltimore, A&M Composting, Natural Soils, Spotsylvania (VA) and many small facilities). Two new, large compost facilities under development in reach of Philadelphia.  DELCORA and ALCOSAN are large utilities with sludge Incinerators; others in NY (Rochester), NJ (ACUA) and VA have upgraded to meet new MACT standards.  The US’s principal service companies, Synagro and Denali, have main offices in the MABA region and serve hundreds of agency clients NYC is the sole large facility in the US without a pathway to Class A EQ products. PVSC is the exclusive example of a long-tested Zimpro wet oxidation solids treatment, and this agency accepts solids from dozens of agencies.  Co-digestion with high strength organic waste has great reference facilities in the MABA region (Rahway Valley SA, Lehigh County Authority, and Hermitage, PA). Landis Sewerage Authority in Vineland NJ is arguably the “greenest” WRRF, with zero effluent discharge and wholly onsite biosolids use.

The narrative also sets the stage for understanding how Pennsylvania, producer of significant biosolids, is also a destination for biosolids from other states. The nature of Pennsylvania’s “accommodative” regulation of biosolids, and similarly restrictive rules in New Jersey, Delaware, and Maryland, ensures that the transport of biosolids regionally and in the direction of Pennsylvania is a significant part of the story of biosolids management regionally. This role is only indirectly revealed in the NBDP. That is because the survey was structured to discuss for each state the mass of biosolids production and the utilization outlets for those state-generated biosolids.  

Though the NBDP is the latest information source available to us biosolids practitioners, in a way it is already outdated. Since the 2018 target year for data collection, pressures on two major categories, landfill disposal and land application, have increased.  Important issue areas of PFAS contamination worries, risks of new regulations of soil phosphorus, and the experience of inadequate seasonal storage have underscored the challenges of maintaining farmland for biosolids applications.  But landfill owners have tightened access by biosolids generators to municipal landfills. This is not only a challenge to Pennsylvania agencies, but more widely to agencies in adjoining states in the mid-Atlantic, which have been reliant on Pennsylvania destinations.  

The other side of this “challenges” coin with biosolids in the MABA region is the opportunities for development of merchant facilities and innovative technologies. These include existing innovative facilities, such as  regional composting (A&M Composting, Burlington Co-Composting and Rockland County Composting), thermal hydrolysis combined with mesophilic digestion (DC Water and HRSD), co-digestion plants (e.g., Hermitage Food Waste to Energy Facility) and drying processes (Synagro in Philadelphia and Baltimore).  Indeed, the MABA region is a landing place for emerging thermal biosolids solutions, such as pyrolysis (BioForceTech), hydrothermal carbonization (SOMAX Bioenergy ), PA and gasification (EarthCare, EcoRemedy and Aries Clean Energy) --  solutions that seem to be particularly urgent in this time of PFAS.

The National Biosolids Data Project demonstrates that the mid-Atlantic region, responsible for nearly a quarter of the nation’s biosolids generation. It is your foundation for understanding future opportunities for biosolids management. Go use it: http://biosolidsdata.org. And, we who helped to assemble the database also will welcome corrections and updates as you find them worthwhile for keeping the information current and accurate, and you can do so by contacting Mary Firestone at  [email protected].

 
More Articles...
<< first < Prev 1 2 Next > last >>

Page 1 of 2